Refactoring long calls

Consider seeing this code in a view. It seems a little long, and may be a candidate for refactoring. Lets see how we can make it better.

<%=
  event.ticket
    .custom_message
    .to_s.strip
    .gsub("[URL]", site_url)
%>

First attempt

One way to rewrite this is to make it as short as possible, ie, store all the complexity in a helper function. In my opinion, this isn't really ideal for the following reasons:

<%= custom_message_for(event) %>
def custom_message_for(event)
  event.ticket
    .custom_messag
    .to_s.strip
    .gsub("[URL]", site_url)
end
  1. Same complexity, new location. The complexity was simply moved from one part to another, instead of broken down into more easily-understandable chunks.

  2. Tight coupling. The method custom_message_for is too tightly coupled. To test this, you will need to create a mock event, with a mock ticket, with a mock custom message.

Second attempt

I would prefer this to be written as a helper that takes in a string, such as so. The view code may be a little longer, but you get these advantages:

= format_message(event.ticket.custom_message)
def format_message(message)
  message.to_s.strip.gsub("[URL]", site_url)
end
  1. Simple and obvious. The method format_message is simple and its purpose is immediately obvious.

  2. Understandable at a glance. Glancing at the view code (format_message(event...)), it's apparent how the message is being derived.

  3. Easy testing. It can be easily tested—just need to pass it a string.

Another way to implement this is with a presenter, which may not be a bad idea either.